Low Box | Composite Sqdn. | |
Stations – _____ | Stations - _____ | |
Start Engines – _____ | Stations - _____ | |
Taxi - _____ | Taxi - _____ | |
Take Off - _____ | Take Off - _____ | |
Leave Base - _____ | Leave Base - ____ |
Diversions - | 1st Division | 40th, 41st Comp., 40th C.W. [Combat Wing] |
2nd Division | 3 C.W's - 24's [B-24's] | |
3rd Division | 4 C.B.W.'s | |
Mediums |
[Radio] | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Call Sign | Flares | Channels | Tail Letter | |
94th C.B.W. [Combat Wing] | Ragweed | RY [Red Yellow] | A | |
351st A | Ragweed Red | G | A | J |
401st | Ragweed White | A | S | |
Composite Group | Ragweed Pink | B | ||
Air Commander | Checkmate | B | ||
1st C.B.W. | Goonchild | RR | A, L | |
40th C.B.W. | Bulpenn | YY | B, G, H | |
41st C.B.W. | Fatgal | GG | C, K, P | |
U.S. Fighters | Denver One | C | ||
Bombers | Goldsmith One Two | C | ||
Grnd. Control | Tackline | |||
R.A.F. Fighters | Garlic One | C (Special) | ||
Bombers | DyePeg One Two | C (Special) | ||
Grnd. Control | Spicecake |
Time | Color | Ident. | Challenge |
---|---|---|---|
0700 - 1300 | R-RR [Red - Red Red] | B | Q |
1300 - 1900 | GY | V | Y |
1900 - 0100 | Y-YR | Z | D |
STATISTICAL SUMMARY | Low | Low Sqdn. |
---|---|---|
Group | High Group | |
No. of A/C Scheduled | 17 | 6 |
No. of A/C Taking Off | 17 | 6 |
Unused Spares | 0 | 0 |
A/C taking off less unused spares | 17 | 6 |
No. of A/C leaving England | 17 | 5 |
No. of Sorties | 17 | 5 |
No. of A/C Attacking | 13 | 5 |
No. of A/C Not Attacking | 4 | 0 |
No. of A/C Lost | 5 | 1 |
To Flak | 0 | 0 |
To Flak and Enemy A/C | 0 | 0 |
To Enemy Aircraft | 5 | 0 |
Accident | 0 | 0 |
Unknown | 0 | 1 |
Group: 351st Bomb Group
Target: KÖNIGSLUTTER, GERMANY
Method of Bombing: GROUP
Altitude: 18,250 ft.
Direction of Attack: 333° Mag. [Magnetic Compass Heading]
Wind Direction: 282°
Wind Speed: 30 MPH
Bombardier - Lt. Thomas E. Trolinger Pilot - Lt. Donald E. Floden Navigator - Lt. William D. Badger
Aircraft # 42-37825 Take-off - 0815 Landed - 1530
Objective - Oschersleben, Germany, A/C Assembly Plant
Aiming Point (MPI)[Mean Point of Impact] - Assembly Shops and Buildings
Initial Point - Goslar, Germany
Method of Attack - Group
Number of Planes in Group - 18 Composite Group -
Number A/C Dropping Bombs by own sighting operation -
Deflection and Range sighting, Group - One Composite Group -
Range Sighting only, Group - One Composite Group -
Bombs, Types and Sizes - M-43 – 500# G.P [General Purpose]
Number of Bombs Loaded - 12 – 500# G.P. per A/C Released - 12
Fusing, Nose - 1/10 Tail - 1/40
Synchronization - On
Altitude of Target - _____ | Magnetic Heading Ordered 83° Actual 333° | |
True Altitude Above Target - 18,250 | True Heading 328° | |
Indicated Altitude - 19,000 | Drift, Estimated 3° Right - Actual 4° Right | |
Pressure Altitude of Target -40 | True Track 332° | |
Altimeter Setting | Actual Range | |
Calculated Indicated Air Speed - 150 M.P.H. | B.S. Type - M-9 | |
True Air Speed - 186 M.P.H. | Time of Release | |
Ground Speed Est. 145 Actual 172 | Length of Bombing Run - 90 sec. | |
Wind Direction Metro - 320° Actual - 282° | Intervalometer Setting - Min. | |
Wind Velocity Metro 50 Actual 30 | C-1 Pilot[Autopilot] X [used] | |
D.S. - 152.1 Trail - 42 ATF - 40.1 | A-5 Pilot _____ | |
Tan. D.A, Est. _____ Actual .44 | Manual Pilot _____ |
Type of Release - Train
Point of Impact If Seen - Target Area
Mean Temp. Metro _____ Actual -15° C.
Winds - Altitude - _____ Direction - Est. _____ Actual _____ Velocity - Est. _____ Actual _____ Temp C. - Est. _____ Actual _____
[All Bombardier's dropped their Bombs when Lead Group Bombardier dropped his Bombs.]
Paragraph 7: These details are known about the following missing A/C: 861-X [42-29861], 481-B [42-31481] and 523-M [42-3523] were all reported
shot down by rockets from E/A [Enemy Aircraft] just around the IP [Initial Point of Bomb Run] within a few minutes of each other. 861-X and
523-M went down at the same time and 481-B soon afterwards.
From the latter A/C [Aircraft] four parachutes were seen. The crews were so busy about this time they did not have a chance to follow the
other distressed A/C, therefore details are meager. 780-T [42-30780] was seen straggling just after the bombed target with a badly shattered
tail. 905-C [42-39905] was in distress just before the briefed primary, and seven parachutes were reported. 761-D [42-39761], which was the
only A/C lost from the low squadron of the Composite Group, was straggling behind the formation over Holland on the route back with two
fighters on his tail. One of the fighters was knocked down and the other turned away. This A/C was still going when last seen by our
A/C.
[Signed] John L. Scott, Major, Air Corps, Group S-2 [Intelligence]
Target - Oschersleben Time Bombs Away: 1206 hours
1. Route followed. - Egmond, Dümmer Lake, Clausthal, 5 mi. SE of Halberstadt, Oschersleben, 5 mi. West of Gifhorn, Dümmer Lake,
3 mi. North Ijmuiden.
2. Visibility at Target. - Clear Contrails - None
3. Position of Group in relation to other Groups: Low
4. General Axis of attack (Lead A/C) - 333 Degrees Magnetic [Compass Heading].
5. Length of Straight and Level Bomb Run: 1 minute
6. Evasive Action Taken? - Right and left turns
7. Turn after Bombing. - None
8.(a)Number of A/C Damaged By A/A [Antiaircraft] Gunfire:
(b)Number of A/C Lost to A/A Gunfire:
9. Description of Flak, including type of Fire Control used:
(a) Route out: At Lingen and Wesepe flak was observed below the formation. These bursts were small, and appeared to be small caliber gun.
Moderate, black flak, accurate for deflection but not altitude, encountered at Helmstedt. Continuous following.
(b) Target: None
(c) Route back: Hannover: Moderate flak, black, poor for altitude, and out of range. Ijmuiden (Coast): Meager flak, fair for height and
deflection. Predicted concentration.
10. Comments, Phenomena: One crew reports that between IP and primary, probably near Halberstadt, 3 rocket shells burst in front of ship.
The bursts were pink flashes which threw out burning objects attached to small white chutes. Two of these burning objects drifted within
100 feet of the ship, and it was distinctly seen that they were attached to small chutes.
11. No. of A/C Carrying "Window" [Chaff]: None dropped by this group.
Observed Results:____
Target - Oschersleben Time Bombs Away: 1156 hours
1. Route followed. - Egmond, South end of Dümmer Lake, Clausthal, 5 mi. SE of Halberstadt, Oschersleben, 10 mi. West of Gifhorn, North
edge of Dümmer Lake, 7 mi. North of Ijmuiden.
2. Visibility at Target. - Clear Contrails - None
3. Position of Group in relation to other Groups: High
4. General Axis of attack (Lead A/C) - 200 Degrees Magnetic.
5. Length of Straight and Level Bomb Run: 1 minute
6. Evasive Action Taken? - Right and left turns
7. Turn after Bombing. - Left
8.(a)Number of A/C Damaged By A/A [Antiaircraft] Gunfire:
(b)Number of A/C Lost to A/A Gunfire:
9. Description of Flak, including type of Fire Control used:
(a) Route out: Several black, inaccurate bursts observed over Minden. Several large inaccurate bursts, pink in color seen in Halberstadt
area. Those were inaccurate for altitude but in front of formation.
(b) Target: 8 bursts of black flak seen in target area. These were black and inaccurate for both altitude and deflection.
(c) Route back: Moderate flak observed over Hannover. This was black, accurate for altitude, but this group was to the right and well out
of range.
10. Comments, Phenomena: None
11. No. of A/C Carrying "Window" [Chaff]: None dropped by this group.
Observed Results:____
A/C 831-H, 510th Squadron: “I wish to mention that the gunners of our group were on the ball. Many E/A were shot down without claim. The
formation under attack was fine.” - Lt. Eickhoff, Pilot.
[Signed] John L. Scott, Major, Air Corps, Group S-2 [Intelligence]
TOTAL A/C DAMAGED | MINOR DAMAGE | BY FLAK | BY FLAK, FRIEND, FIGHTER | |||
3 | 3 | 2 | 1 |
TOTAL A/C DAMAGED | MINOR DAMAGE | BY FLAK | BY FLAK and FIGHTER | |||
6 | 6 | 4 | 2 |
1. The Station Ordnance Officer has submitted an estimated expenditure of 118,000 rounds of Caliber .50 ammunition for the Mission of 11 January, 1944. This figure includes 54,000 Rounds of Ammunition in the six aircraft missing in action.
1. The Station Ordnance Officer has reported that 4,125 rounds of .50 Cal ammunition were expended on the Mission of 22 December, 1943.
1. Following is the disposition of bombs on the Mission of 11 January, 1944.
LOW GROUP | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
AIRCRAFT | BOMBS | FUSING | |||||
Over Target | Bombing | Number | Size | Type | Nose Tail | ||
Main Bombfall - (Königslutter) | 13 | 13 | 114 | 500 lb. | M-43 | 1/10 1/100 | |
Total Bombs on Target | 114 | 500 lb. | M-43 | 1/10 1/100 | |||
Bombs on 4 A/C Reported as MIA before Target | 42 | 500 lb. | M-43 | 1/10 1/100 | |||
TOTAL BOMBS LOADED | 156 | 500 lb. | M-43 | 1/10 1/100 |
1. The following data indicates the disposition of bombs on the Mission of this date:
AIRCRAFT | BOMBS | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Over Target | Bombing | Number | Size | Type | Fusing | ||
Main Bombfall (Primary Target) | 5 | 5 | 144 | 100 lb. | M-47 | Instantaneous | |
Total Bombs on Target | 144 | 100 lb. | M-47 | Instantaneous | |||
Bombs Returned | 18 | 100 lb. | M-47 | Instantaneous | |||
TOTAL BOMBS LOADED | 162 | 100 lb. | M-47 | Instantaneous |
MAXIMUM LOAD OF THREE SIX [36] M FOUR SEVEN [M-47] INCENDIARY BOMBS WITH M ONE ZERO EIGHT [M-108] FUZES WILL BE LOADED USING SIX AND ONE HALF INCH TOGGLE SLINGS. BOMBS WILL BE SUSPENDED AS FOLLOWS: SINGLE BOMBS ON OUTBOARD ONE HUNDRED POUND STATION NUMBERS ONE, THREE, FOUR, TWELVE, FOUTEEN, TWENTY-TWO, TWENTY-FOUR, TWENTY-FIVE, THIRTY-THREE, AND THIRTY-FIVE: DOUBLE BOMBS ON ALL INBOARD ONE HUNDRED POUND STATION NUMBERS FIVE, SEVEN, NINE, FIFTEEN, SEVENTEEN, NINETEEN, TWENTY-SIX, TWENTY-EIGHT, THIRTY, THIRTY-SIX, THIRTY-EIGHT AND FORTY. NUMBERS TWENTY-ONE AND FORTY-TWO WILL CARRY ONE SINGLE BOMB EACH. UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES EXCEPT EXTREME EMERGENCY WILL BOMBS ARMED WITH M ONE ZERO EIGHT [M-108] FUZES BE SALVOED.
Aircraft No. P-42-3136 Squadron 511 Pilot - Lt. R.D. McCarthy
Time of Abortive - 0900 Location when Aborted - Deenethorpe
Reason - Gas fumes throughout entire ship.
Enemy Opposition Encountered - None
[Signed:] R. D. McCarthy
Altitude: 8,300 feet Disposition of Bombs: On Board
Interrogation of B-17 Crew A/C Number 749Z 351st Gp.:
351st Gp. A/C 845 went down 1125 at 52°05’N - 09°20’E, afire 9 chutes seen. [Handwritten in] This A/C scheduled to fly but did not take
off. [Pilot:](Bartzocas)
351st Gp. A/C 905 [Handwritten in, Pilot:] Garner, Number 2 Position, 2nd Element, Lead Sqdn., afire at 1130, Target area, dove down from 19,000 [feet].
7 chutes.
351st Gp. A/C 861 [Handwritten in, Pilot:] Cannon, Number 2 Engine, wings shot up, straggled back, lost to sight.
B-17 Gp. “G” Letter N, vertical stabilizer shot away, straggler, lost sight of near Dutch Coast.
B-17 Gp. “B” Letter V or Y, at 1315, 30 minutes before reaching coast, dropped wheels, went down, Number 3 afire, from 15,000 [feet], wing,
tail blew off. No chutes.
a. Lead Box | |
Sqdn 508th A/C: 9654–B, 9858–G, 9849–V* | (3) |
Sqdn 509th A/C: 9863–Y, 9749–Z, 9861–X, 0780–T* | (4) |
Sqdn 510th A/C: 9905–C*, 9948–J, 8028–Q*, 9835–N*, 9831–H, 1481–B*, 3523–M*, 9925–L | (8) |
Sqdn 511th A/C: 7825–Q*, 7780–G* | (7) |
b. Composite Sqdn. Flying Low Sqdn. High Box | |
Sqdn 508th A/C: | (0) |
Sqdn 509th A/C: | (0) |
Sqdn 510th A/C: | (0) |
Sqdn 511th A/C: 9857–H*, 9761–D*, 9834–F*, 9849–U, 3136–P, 9835–Y | (6) |
* Denotes A/C with Tokyo Tanks |
Squadron | 508 Call Sign | WDB Daisy Chain | Squadron | 510 Call Sign | UYZ Paramount | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Squadron | 509 Call Sign | MFR Riding Whip | Squadron | 511 Call Sign | LXD Thick Frost |
Time: | Height: | Place of crossing English Coast OUT: |
---|---|---|
1003 | 15,000 Ft | Lowestoft |
Time: | Height: | Place of Recrossing Enemy Coast: |
---|---|---|
1330 | 20,000 Ft | 52°37'N - 04°37'E |
Time: | Height: | Place of crossing English Coast IN: |
---|---|---|
1410 | 5,000 Ft | Great Yarmouth |
Squadron | A/C No. & Letter | A.T.O. | A.T.R. | Squadron | A/C No. & Letter | A.T.O. | A.T.R. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
508 | 9654–B | 0824 | 509 | 9863–Y | 0829½ | ||
9858–G | 0823½ | 9749–Z | 0830 | ||||
9849–V | 0825 | 9861–X | 0833 | ||||
7845–F | Scrubbed | ||||||
0780–T | 0835 | ||||||
510 | 9905–C | 0828 | 511 | 7825–Q | 0823 | ||
9848–F | 0831 | 7780–G | 0824½ | ||||
8028–Q | 0832 | ||||||
9835–N | 0827 | ||||||
9831–H | 0826 | ||||||
1481–B | 0826½ | ||||||
9925–L | 0828½ | ||||||
3523–M | 0850½ |
Squadron | A/C No. & Letter | A.T.O. | A.T.R. | Squadron | A/C No. & Letter | A.T.O. | A.T.R. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
511 | 9857–H | 0458½ | |||||
9761–D | 0510 | ||||||
9834–F | 0504 | ||||||
9849–U | 0504½ | ||||||
3136–P | 0821 | 1036 | |||||
9835–Y | 0830½ | ||||||
Report Compiled By Rocky F. Civizzio
Sqdn. | A/C Letter | Designation | Box | Remarks |
---|---|---|---|---|
511 | 3136–P | Abortive | Composite | Terrific Gas Fumes in Ship |
Group Formation Take–Off | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
508th Squadron | ||||||||
Floden – Oldham A/C # 42-37825 Q | ||||||||
Apperson A/C # 42-29654 B | Blaisdell A/C # 42-29858 G | |||||||
McCafferty A/C # 42-37780 G | ||||||||
Rhode A/C # 42-39849 V | Garner A/C # 42-39905 C | |||||||
509th Squadron | 510th Squadron | |||||||
Brooksby A/C # 42-29863 Y | McCluskey A/C # 42-38028 Q | |||||||
Songer A/C # 42-29848 F | McLawhorn A/C # 42-29749 Z | Knapp A/C # 42-39835 N | Eickhoff A/C # 42-29831 H | |||||
Cannon A/C # 42-29861 X | Case A/C # 42-31481 B | |||||||
W. Meyers A/C # 42-30780 T | Winton A/C # 42-29925 L | Procak A/C # 42-3523 M |
Group Formation Over Target of Opportunity | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
508th Squadron | ||||||||
Floden – Oldham A/C # 42-37825 Q | ||||||||
Apperson A/C # 42-29654 B | Blaisdell A/C # 42-29858 G | |||||||
McCafferty A/C # 42037780 G | ||||||||
Rhode A/C # 42-39849 V | ||||||||
509th Squadron | 510th Squadron | |||||||
Brooksby A/C # 42-29863 Y | McCluskey A/C # 42-38028 Q | |||||||
Songer A/C # 42-29848 F | McLawhorn A/C # 42-29749 Z | Knapp A/C # 42-39835 N | Eickhoff A/C # 42-29831 H | |||||
W. Meyers A/C # 42-30780 T | Winton A/C # 42-29925 L |
Formation Take–Off | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
511th Squadron | ||||||||
Litsinger A/C # 42-39857 H | ||||||||
Mears A/C # 42-39834 F | White A/C # 42-39761 D | |||||||
Sherman A/C # 42-29849 U | ||||||||
McCarthy A/C # 42-3136 P | Pryor A/C # 42-29835 Y |
Group Formation Over Target of Opportunity | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
511th Squadron | ||||||||
Litsinger A/C # 42-39857 H | ||||||||
Mears A/C # 42-39834 F | White A/C # 42-39761 D | |||||||
Sherman A/C # 42-29849 U | ||||||||
Pryor A/C # 42-29835 Y |
The assigned target was an aircraft factory and assembly at Oschersleben, Germany. Only six planes from the 511th Squadron, flying in a composite box, bombed the primary target. The other planes attacked a target of opportunity at Konigslutter. Twenty-two planes flew the mission, led by Captain Oldham and Lt. Floden with Lt. Badger as navigator and Lt. Trollinger as bombardier. The bombing of the squadron in the composite box was unobserved, but the others dropped their bombs in the northeast section of Konigslutter. The German Air Force evidently made an all out effort to stop this raid, sending up from 100 to 150 fighters. This included FW 189s, FW 100s, ME 109s, ME 110s, ME 210s, DO 217s, JU 88s and even a few Stukas. They began their attacks immediately after the fighter escort left a few minutes before the I.P. and continued for 45 minutes. The single-engine fighters employed their familiar tactics, peeling off in echelons of from two to five and barrel rolling through the formation from all directions. The JU 88s tried air-to-air bombing, while the twin-engine planes used rocket-firing guns. ME 210s flying behind the wing in similar formation were not recognized for what they were until they suddenly peeled off in trail for vicious tail attacks. Six planes were shot down by the fighters. Lt. Cannon in 42-29861, Lt. Garner in 42-39905, Lt. Case in 42-31481, and Lt. Procak in 42-3523 went down between the I.P. and the target. Lt. Myers in 42-30780 and Lt. White in 42-39761 went down after bombing the target. The loss of Lts. Cannon and Myers ended a remarkable run. The 509th Squadron had flown 52 missions during some of the fiercest air battles the Group was to encounter. These were the first losses due to enemy action since June 13, 1943. All surviving aircraft had to land at coastal airfields on their return to England as 9/10 stratus covered Polebrook.
A/C# 42-29861 RQ-X "Buckshot" Pilot: 1st Lt. Cannon, Harold C. A/C's 31st Mission MACR # 1936
Aircraft Loss Circumstances:
According to the book "The 351st Bomb Group in WWII," page 36, the plane was shot down by German fighters.
In a statement filed in the MACR, John E. May, the Co-pilot stated, "All Crew bailed out at approx. the same time. Navigator Lt. Georg M.
Farrell - Back wound. Bombardier Lt. Robert H. Wood - Shot in arm & hand." The aircraft struck the ground, "Within 2 miles from bailout." A
German document misfiled in MACR 1937 says that A/C 42-29861 crashed 7 km east of Salzgitter, Germany between 1215 and 1220 hours. The plane
was 95 percent destroyed and was scattered over an area of 300 meters. According to statements one engine was on fire when it crashed.
A/C# 42-39905 YB-C Pilot: 1st Lt. Thomas D. Garner A/C's 2nd Mission MACR # 1937
Aircraft Loss Circumstances:
According to the book "The 351st Bomb Group in WWII," page 36, the plane was shot down by German fighters.
According to a document in the MACR filled out by a crew member it states, "It is
believed the tail gunner, Ralph C. Foster, was shot going out the door and was dead when he got out. That he was shot in the back by machine
gun fire that hit his heart."
Another questionaire filed by a crew member says, "Thomas D. Garner, pilot, told me that the Germans told him that Ralph C. Foster's chute
had never opened. I was told by my pilot that he had been shot through the heart and was killed instantly." He was buried in Weissenborn,
Germany on 13 Jan. 1944.
A crew member's statement in the MACR reads, "Erwin G. Huggett was in the hospital in Nordhausen with his arm off and had a blood transfusion
from the pilot." He died the next day and was buried in Nordhausen Cemetery on the 14 Jan. 1944 at 1100.
The burial records below courtesy of the American Battle Monuments Commission. http://www.abmc.gov and findagrave.com
A/C# 42-31481 TU-B Pilot: Lt. Richard J. Case A/C's 1st Mission MACR #1941
Aircraft Loss Circumstances:
According to the book "The 351st Bomb Group in WWII," page 36, the plane was shot down by German fighters.
The documents in the MACR report that the aircraft was attacked by German fighters and the tail gunner Raymond E. Howard was hit. The whole
crew except Howard bailed out and the plane crashed near Gottingen, Germany. After they were captured Howard's body was removed from the plane
by the pilot and the left waist gunner, Simmons. They carried his body in a truck from the plane to a small town between Hanover and Gottingen.
There the Germans took care of him. Howard was not a regular crew member. He was a fill in on that last mission.
The burial records below courtesy of the American Battle Monuments Commission. http://www.abmc.gov
A/C# 42-3523 TU-M "April Girl" Pilot: 2nd Lt. George J. Procak A/C's 11th Mission MACR #1940
Aircraft Loss Circumstances:
According to the book "The 351st Bomb Group in WWII," page 36, the plane was shot down by German fighters.
In the MACR # 1940 there is paperwork dated 21 August 1945 requesting the Commanding Officer of 1020 AAF Base unit, Miami Beach, Florida,
to interrogate 2nd Lt. George B Neely [the co-pilot] with reference to any information which he may know concerning the whereabouts of the
left waist gunner,d Sergeant Peter J. Goinvic.
1. Second Lieutenant George B. Neely, 0654391, has been interrogated by this office regarding the status of Sergeant Peter J. Goinvic. He
furnished the following information:
Lieutenant Neely was co-pilot on a B-17 plane on a mission to bomb Oschersleben, Germany, on 11 January 1944. The target time was about
1150 hours. About thirty (30) minutes before reaching the target, Lt. Neely's plane was subjected to a furious attack by eight (8) enemy
fighters. The altitude was 20,000 feet. The plane received 20-mm hits from nose to tail. The bomb bay section was set afire which
prevented Lt. Neely from going to the rear of the plane. One burst of 20-mm shell entered the cockpit and injured the pilot severely in the
right leg and foot. This was followed by a hit in the waist section by a rocket. Lt. Neely saw the pilot pull the bailout alarm. At this
time both wings of the plane were on fire. Lt. Neely then went into the nose of the plane and found the bombardier and engineer attempting
to reach the fire with a fire extinguisher. Lt. Neely then indicated to them that they were to leave the plane. He then reached up and got
his parachute, tapped the pilot on the leg and indicated that he was leaving the plane. He then left the plane by the nose escape hatch.
While he was in the air, Lt. Neely counted three (3) parachutes in the air in addition to his own.
He landed some distance from the other crew members and did not join them until two (2) days later at Paderborne, Germany, where he found
Lieutenant J.S. Trumbower and Sergeant Cipriano. Since both of these men had been in the nose section neither of them know anything of the
events that occurred in the rear of the plane. He was taken to Dulag Luft at Frankfort and the only information furnished him by the
interrogators there was that Sergeant Burgess had been killed and his body was found in the tail section of the plane which broke away after
the rocket hit.
2. Lieutenant Neely furnishes the following hearsay information:
While he was at Lucky Strike Camp at LeHavre, France, [after being liberated from POW camp] he talked to Sergeant Williams who told him
that before he left the plane he put parachutes on Sergeant Goinvic and Sergeant Chelstowski, both of whom had been severely hurt and whom
he thought were dead. Sergeant Williams then threw both men out the waist door. Sergeant Williams said that he knew that the tail gunner
had been hit and was probably dead but he could not reach him. He then obtained his own parachute and left the plane. Sergeant Williams
also told Lieutenant Neely that he was the last one to leave the plane from the rear section.
3. Lieutenant Neely estimates that the scene of the crash was approximately fifty (50) miles east of Paderborne.
4. It is the opinion of Lieutenant Neely that Sergeants Williams and Chelstowski could furnish the best information regarding Sergeant
Goinvic. He is also of the opinion that if Sergeant Williams' story can be corroborated, he should be cited for gallantry above and
beyond the call of duty.
[Signed:] Theodore J Hieatt, Major, Air Corps, Chief, intelligence and Security Division.
Sergeant Eugene R. Chelstowski the right waist gunner was also interrogated as to what happened to Sergeant Goinvic. The document states:
In interrogation of Sergeant Eugene R. Chelstowski, information was brought to light that the left waist gunner on this particular mission
had been introduced to him that day as "Hughes." Sgt. Chelstowski further states, that both he and the left waist gunner were hit in the
face and head by flak to the extent that neither could see the other thereafter. He states that both left the ship, but that he does not
know whether chute opened, since he could not see the other man concerned.
T/Sgt John J. Cipriano was interrogated on 5 Sept. 1945 and gave this statement in an affidavit:
"On the 11 January 1944 I was flying Engineer Gunner of the crew on a B-17 airplane. At this time I was stationed in England. S/Sgt. Otis L.
Williams, ball turret gunner, Sgt Eugene R. Chelstowski, right gunner - waist, S/Sgt Peter J. Goinvic, left waist gunner, T/Sgt Sol E. Susman,
radio operator, S/Sgt E.T. Burgess, tail gunner, Lt. George J. Procak, 1st Pilot, Lt George B. Neely, Co-pilot, Lt. James P. Keating,
Bombardier, Lt. Jerry S. Trumbower, Navigator, and I were crew members of this B-17. At this time all were members of the 351st Bomb Group,
510 Bomb Squadron. On that day we took part in an air raid over Germany. The plane was shot down just before we reached the target. The
tail gunner was dead in the plane and we left him there. Everybody else bailed out."
I later saw S/Sgt Otis L. Williams after we were captured. He told me that he put chutes on Sgt Eugene R. Chelstowski and S/Sgt Peter J.
Goinvic and helped them get out of the plane when we bailed out. He said, "They were wounded and needed help." He further said that S/Sgt
Peter J. Goinvic was "Still missing." I have no personal knowledge about the whereabouts of S/Sgt Peter J. Goinvic." [Signed] John J.
Cipriano
Other documents in the MACR, from German records, report that plane 42-3523 crashed at Pilgrin, Germany, 3 km. south east of Schörborn and
was scattered over a 1 km. radius.
Another German document in the MACR reports that Williams, Keating, Procak and Susman were captured by a Policeman in the vicinity of
Silberborn on 11 Jan. 1944 between 1300 and 1700 o'clock and were delivered to the Army Airbase at Goettingen on 15 January 1944.
The burial records below courtesy of the American Battle Monuments Commission. http://www.abmc.gov and findagrave.com
A/C# 42-30780 RQ-T "Eager Eagle II" Pilot: 2nd Lt William H. Myers A/C's 10th Mission MACR #1938
Aircraft Loss Circumstances:
German fighter aircraft attacked the plane from five o'clock high. The plane went into a spin and exploded before anyone had
a chance to bailout.
Lt. William Carmichael, the navigator, wrote in a casualty questionnaire filed in the MACR: "Sgt William N. Bloshko, Sgt Herbert H. Bivens
and myself were either blown out of the plane by the explosion or thrown out due to the disintegration of the plane at approximately 1125
hours, 11 Jan. 1944, approximately 30 miles south of Hanover. The questionnaire also asked: "In what condition did you last see any
members of the crew."
His reply was: "Sgt Bivens and Bloshko both were seen in LeHave, France [Camp Lucky Strike] after the defeat of Germany and were in good
condition." Sgt. Bivens had spent six months in German hospitals for a bullet wound treatment. He was injured in the plane and the bullet had
nicked his spine. Lt. Carmichael also reported that John Hart, the copilot, was at the nose escape hatch, had released the door
just before the explosion. He had not jumped when the plane went into a dive.
Carmichael also said he handed Arthur Jones, the Bombardier, his parachute pack and believes Jones was
pinned in the nose section because of the spinning plane and couldn't get out.
The top turret gunner, Clyde Caudle, is believed to have gone down with the plane as he was not seen at the nose escape hatch or in the fuselage
and the bomb bay doors were closed so he couldn't have escaped that way.
The radio operator, Lavern Sherman's body was reported to have been seen close to the wreckage of the plane with his parachute unopened.
Whether he was thrown out of the plane or failure of his chute to open is unknown. The crew member reported he didn't believe Sherman had a chance
to bail out as the bomb bay doors were closed and he was not seen at the nose hatch or in the fuselage.
The waist gunners reported the Ball Turret Gunner, Herbert Bivens, had exited the ball turret, put on his parachute and was ready to
leave the plane immediately before the explosion and disintegration of the plane. The crew member did not believe he was able to bail out
because the plane was in a spin.
The condition of Mansfield, the tail gunner, was described in the MACR by a fellow crew member as "severely wounded" but he was able to crawl
to the waist section, his arm practically shot off, and in semi-conscious condition due to loss of blood. He had left his parachute in the
tail section and went down with the plane.
The burial records below courtesy of the American Battle Monuments Commission. http://www.abmc.gov and findagrave.com
A/C# 42-39761 DS-D "Fireball II" Pilot: 2nd Lt. Thompson E. White A/C's 13th Mission MACR #1939
The radio operator, Harry Kratz, wrote in a questionnaire filed in the MACR: "that the plane crashed near Sleen, Holland at 1330 hours. The plane's No. 4 engine was shot out and could not feather the propeller and No.1 engine was knocked out and feathered: No. 2 engine was hit and caught fire as did the left wing." All members of the crew bailed out at 5000 feet and all their chutes opened. The plane blew up just before it hit the ground. Sgt. Elkin saw Sgt. Hitow being led off after landing, he heard Hitow was taken to the hospital because a flak burst had torn his tail guns to pieces and filled his hand full of metal and leather from his gloves. In prison camp he was still removing some of them. Several crew members heard the the pilot, 2nd Lt. Thompson White broke an ankle when landing in his chute. Sgt Elkin was hiding in the woods and later met up with Sgt. Kratz, Sgt. Snyder and Sgt. Mellen. These four men evaded capture and traveled through France toward Spain. Sgt. Clyde Mellen wrote in a questionnaire, "Kratz, Elkins and Snyder [were] last seen on border of Spain and France. I was captured and they made it into Spain. All three were in good condition. Date was 6 Feb 1944. Soderling, Watson and Hitow I found in the prison camp, Stalag 17B. All were in good condition but Hitow, who had a lot of flak in one hand.
Individual Accounts of Crewmen Fates: